Friday, July 11, 2014

A Tale of Two Slaves (Part 2)

Continued from the February 2014 blog entry, "A Tale of Two Slaves" (Part 1).........
________________________________________________________________________
An Indentured Family
In October 1872, Ruffin indentured himself and his heirs to William and Ferebee Lovelace, an older couple likely known to the DeHarts for many years.  Per the deed, "Ruffin....binds himself and his heirs to furnish the said Wm. Lovelace and family with bread, meat, coffee, vegitables (sic), milk and surch (sic) other articles of food as may be produced on the farm and in case of sickness he is to furnish such articles of _______ as we Wm. & Ferebee Lovelace may require and can be procured.  The said Ruffin D. Hart....binds himself and his heirs to give all needful attention to the said Wm. Lovelace and his wife Ferebee Lovelace in sickness and in health to furnish them, the said Lovelace and wife ....with good substantial comfortable clothing.  ......to furnish Wm. Lovelace and family with firewood, to cut the wood up and place in the yard and makes fires when necessary.  This to take place during the natural lives of the Lovelaces ......" 

To be certain, this would have been a tremendous amount of work, however, in consideration of the Ruffin Dehart family's labors, the Lovelaces bequeathed them two tracts of land on the east side of the Little Tennessee River totaling approximately 124 acres.  Not only were the DeHarts to receive the land, but in addition, the agreement with the Lovelaces also provided them 24 head of hogs and 11 head of sheep.  William Lovelace also agreed to raise a colt for the DeHarts if Ruffin would feed her, ".....provided my mare lives".  In addition to the 100 acres they already owned, the start that this would have given Ruffin's family in a life would have been tremendous. 

A portion of the Lovelace / DeHart Indenture
Source: Swain County Register of Deeds Office
Minor Land Barons
Ruffin was not content with a mere 224 acres, however.  In 1884, he purchased an additional 100 acres of land 'on the waters of the Tennessee River', perhaps adjoining the Lovelace property. In 1887, Ruffin went on to purchase 200 acres in the same area from the State of North Carolina, it 'being part of the land lately acquired by treaty from the Cherokee Indians'.  This land was located somewhere in the area of the old Macon County line. During the period between his indenture to the Lovelace family and his purchase of an additional 100 acres in the Little Tennessee river, Ruffin, along with some friends and relatives, purchased, for $115, a two-thirds mining interest in a 450 acre tract of land in the Peachtree and Canebrake-area drainages.  It is likely that some of the family (probably Ruffin and Susan included) moved to this vicinity sometime thereafter, as a nearby area is referred to in old deeds as 'Ni***er Mountain' and older residents of the area knew it as 'Ni***er Cove'. By the time Fontana Dam was constructed and those families residing along the North Shore of Fontana Lake were removed, Jesse DeHart was the only member of the family remaining in the Peachtree area.
 
How a former slave managed to obtain land holdings of this magnitude is not known, but was almost certainly a result of exceptionally hard work on the part of the DeHart family.  It is additionally possible that the Deharts' former masters provided some degree of financial assistance; some evidence in the historical record (discussed in the previous blog posting and in this post) indicates that there was much goodwill between these families.

Jesse DeHart Tract on Peachtree Creek - TVA Survey (circa 1942)
Source: TVA Digital Files and Carol Cochran

 A Colored Man Defended by Whites
During the Reconstruction and Jim Crow eras in the South, the defense of a former slave by white individuals would have been a bit of an anomaly, but it seems that Ruffin must have commanded enough community respect to be an exception.  He found himself in court in April of 1874 along with his sons Henry and 'Alf' on an unknown charge.  What is known, however, is that Martin and Nathan DeHart (most likely two of the sons of Ruffin's former master, John) put up a bond for them. In 1881, J.D. Buchanan pressed a suit (the nature of which is unknown) against Ruffin and William Bryson; the men were ably represented by prominent area attorney Kope Elias (who owned a large farm in the area of the 'Ferguson Fields').  Buchanan dropped the suit, and was also forced to pay Ruffin for expenses incurred in defending it.


Court Record from 1874
Source:  NC State Archives and Don Casada
Uneducated Educators
In her book, 'Swain County:  Early History and Educational Development", Lillian Thomasson noted that school district records for 1881 (kept privately by then-superintendent John Sadoc Smiley), indicated a total of 59 colored children of school age residing in the county.  However, district records also show that between 1889 and 1900, only one schoolhouse for colored students existed.  This almost certainly indicated that a significant number of Swain County's colored students were receiving no formal education.  For the DeHarts, who could neither read nor write and who would eventually have at least 23 grandchildren (census records are not definitive), this cause must have been felt deeply.  On 03 Dec 1887  Ruffin and Susan deeded one acre to the school committee for District #1, "for and in consideration of cause and in promotion of education of the colored race.....for the use and purpose of erecting a school house for the aforesaid colored race".  As all pre-1908 official school records burned in a courthouse fire, there is no way of knowing whether or not the schoolhouse was built for certain; it is not shown in any of the post-1908 school board minutes. Given that the 1900 census records indicate that several of Ruffin's grandchildren were able to read, I personally would like to believe that his school took root and that education allowed his descendants to forge a better life for themselves than they would have had otherwise.
A Black Schoolhouse / Church in the Rural South, 1903
Source:  The Atlantic Monthly (Story Written in 1899, picture added later)
An End to an Extraordinary Life
Ruffin's life came to an end in 1893 at the approximate age of 67.  We know nothing of his death other than that he died without a will. Evidencing the respect Ruffin must have held in the community is the fact that Bryson City mayor and prominent citizen, Epp Everett, was chosen to administer his estate, the contents of which are unknown. Rather than a simple fieldstone, a fine engraved tombstone was erected for him, and another for his wife Susan, who followed him to the grave in 1895.  Today they lie interred in the Watkins cemetery with many of their children and descendants buried nearby.


Identified as Epaphroditus 'Epp' Everett
Pete Prince Collection, University of Tennessee Libraries
A Legacy
The annals of Swain County history record the lives of many of the county's former citizens, both prominent and 'ordinary'.  The Ruffin DeHart family's story is not to be found in these annals, and may be pieced together only by the most painstaking of research.  Yet I find their story a compelling one, exemplifying the triumph of the human spirit over adversity.  It is also an extraordinary story of friendship and respect between African Americans and whites during a time in which racial segregation was the 'Law of the Land' and the Ku Klux Clan instilled terror even in these isolated mountains. 
 
May this 'Tale of Two Slaves' inspire you to develop and cultivate the qualities that led an impoverished slave family to achieve overwhelming success in life and to leave a legacy to those who have followed them.
 

 
The Tombstones of Ruffin and Susan DeHart, Watkins Cemetery
 
 
Note to Readers:  I have put together a partial family tree of the Ruffin and Susan DeHart family on Ancestry.com.  If you are interested in viewing it (as it is set to "Private"), please message me via my 'oldeswain@gmail.com' address and I will send you an invitation.
 
_____________________________________________________________________
Sources: 
Ancestry.com
Don Casada
Carol Cochran
North Carolina State Archives
Pete Prince Collection, University of Tennessee at Knoxville
Thomasson, Lillian: "Swain County:  Early History and Educational Development"
Swain County Register of Deeds Office
The Atlantic Monthly, January 1899
 


9 comments:

  1. As usual, exceptionally well researched and written! This is a fascinating story that few have tried to dig out and of which I knew nothing until this blog. Thank you for all your hard work. Side note - I was aware of the Wm Lovelace family who lived in Swain Co at that time but have never figured out if or how he was related to Sarah Lovelace who married William DeHart (John's brother). Does anyone know anything about this Wm and Ferebee Lovelace family? If so, please contact me and we can share information! Again, great job, Wendy!! Linda Banwarth (lindabanwarth@pobox.com)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Linda!

      I extensively researched the William and Ferebee Lovelace connection to Sarah Lovelace for these two blog entries but, like you, could not find a definitive relationship (though it seems highly unlikely that there would not be one). The indenture mentions a Nancy Carolina Swafford who is living with them, who I believe was a granddaughter.....this may be of some help in your research. I'll send you the indenture.

      Delete
  2. Regarding the point of mining interest acquisition:
    The property which Ruffin's son Jessie owned on Peachtree (tract FR-1009 on the TVA survey map) was bounded on the west by a ridgeline, as indicated. That ridge, which is the dividing line between the Canebrake and Peachtree drainages, is labeled as Mine Mountain on maps that go back to at least 1936.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Curiosity got the best of me and I went through all 29 pages of the 1880 Nantahala, Swain County census just to determine how many non-whites lived there. All of my direct ancestors on my mother's side and on my father paternal side lived there. I found 13 B and MU individuals. 8 of those were the family of William and Alpha H Thomas listed a B (Black) the rest were MU mulatto. Of the other 5, the only one directly connected was Hambleton Tabor, listed as a hired man living with what I presume is William and Sarah Lovelace DeHart my G-G-G-Grandparents. The other 4 were living with people who are kin but not directly. Anderson Davidson lived with Robert H Byrd (no relationship listed). Lucinda Walker lived with Thomas Southards, listed as an apprentice. Milus Rogers lived with John Truitt (I am unsure of the race. It looks like is was changed.) Luisy J Truitt lived with Mary Truitt.
    This is the third time I've tried to comment. The other two ended up in Never Never Land, I presume.

    Thanks for all your work. Please don't ever stop giving life back to people long gone.

    ReplyDelete
  4. John Sadoc Smiley was my G-G-Grandfather. He was the enumerator for the 1880 Nantahala, Swain County census. Being as he was an educated man and an educator, I put a lot of stock in his work on the census although changed could have been made after he submitted his work.
    Lillian Thomasson was my 9th and 10th grade French teacher, s'il vous plait. A remarkable woman she was too.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for commenting, Ed, and I'm so glad these comments finally came through! It is very, very interesting to look at the individuals listed as 'black', 'colored', or 'mulatto' on those old census records....even around 1900 or thereabouts.

    I have the utmost regard for John Sadoc Smiley; Linda is trying to help me track down the papers which Lillian Thomasson mentions in her book. I will keep you posted as to whether or not we're able to find them!!

    I love telling the stories of those long gone - I will never quit. :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, could you tell me if you know anyone who might have more info on the Kitchen family? John coloumbus Kitchen was my g-grandfather. My father was born in Bryson City in 1923. Thanks, Ray Kitchen

      Delete
  6. The j.d. Buchanan you speak of an John dehart do you have any info? My gg was j.d. dehart an his mom is supposedly Nancy buchanan. If anything sounds close please contact me. Missqs68 @ gmail

    ReplyDelete
  7. The j.d. Buchanan you speak of an John dehart do you have any info? My gg was j.d. dehart an his mom is supposedly Nancy buchanan. If anything sounds close please contact me. Missqs68 @ gmail

    ReplyDelete